Why Shedeur Sanders Dropped in the 2025 NFL Draft — And Why It Makes Sense

By George Gentry | April 29, 2025

As the dust settles on the 2025 NFL Draft, analysts and fans alike are scratching their heads over one name that remained on the board far longer than expected: Shedeur Sanders. Once projected as a potential Day 2 selection, Sanders fell to the fifth round—a surprising development for a quarterback with strong statistics and a recognizable name. But to me, the real surprise is that anyone expected otherwise.

I’m not a die-hard college football fan, nor did I follow the Colorado Buffaloes closely last season. But over the past four days, I’ve been inundated with hours of draft coverage and punditry. One thing has become clear: NFL teams didn’t just pass on Sanders because of his performance. They passed because they saw warning signs of something more damaging than inconsistent play—they saw a potentially toxic presence.

In that same four-day window, I heard no more than 90 seconds combined of Shedeur Sanders and his father, Deion Sanders, speaking. Yet, in that brief time, both made it clear that humility is in short supply. The elder Sanders declared publicly that there were certain teams he wouldn’t “allow” his son to play for—an audacious statement in a league where no player, especially a rookie, gets to make such demands. Meanwhile, Shedeur’s own remarks suggested he was used to being singled out, subtly positioning himself above the scrutiny that every other draft prospect faces.

That alone raises red flags. Football is not an individual sport; it thrives on leadership, selflessness, and unity. A successful quarterback doesn’t just complete passes—they inspire belief in the locker room, command respect in the huddle, and own their mistakes when things go wrong. Yet the public persona of Shedeur Sanders, with his designer cars and performative flash, suggests a man more interested in optics than accountability.

Let’s call this what it is: classic signs of a toxic potential employee.

Toxic employees aren’t always obvious at first glance. Sometimes they’re talented, even charismatic. But beneath the surface, their actions can poison a culture. In any workplace—including an NFL franchise—these individuals exhibit behaviors that hurt morale, sabotage progress, or create rifts among teams. They may bully teammates, dodge responsibility, or take credit for others’ efforts. They’re often overly competitive, insensitively brash, or blind to their own egos.

Is that Shedeur Sanders? That remains to be seen—but NFL scouts and executives are trained to spot those red flags. They look not just at arm strength and accuracy, but at attitude, composure, and fit. If they believed Sanders projected the warning signs of a toxic presence—overconfidence, entitlement, insensitivity—then dropping him down the draft board wasn’t a mistake. It was strategy.

And let’s not ignore the role of his father, Deion Sanders. A generational talent and now a high-profile coach, Deion has shown little interest in letting his son develop a public image separate from his own. Instead, he’s wrapped Shedeur in his shadow, defending him, controlling narratives, and framing adversity as conspiracy. But there’s a fine line between support and interference—and in this case, Deion may have taught his son all the wrong lessons about leadership.

The NFL doesn’t just want talent—it demands maturity. If a player walks in acting like the CEO before they’ve proven themselves on the field, they alienate teammates, challenge authority, and distract from the goal of winning.

Some may argue that Shedeur Sanders is simply misunderstood, that confidence is being mistaken for arrogance. But leadership is not about how you shine alone—it’s about how you elevate others. And humility, not hype, is what builds a winning culture.

So why did Shedeur Sanders fall to the fifth round? Because NFL teams weren’t just picking a quarterback. They were protecting their locker rooms.

Please consider supporting open, independent journalism – no contribution is too small!